Key takeaways
- Donor retention rate is the number of last year's donors who gave again this year, divided by all of last year's donors, times 100. Donor churn rate is 100% minus the retention rate.
- In the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's 2025 data, which pools 7.8 million donors at 15,102 nonprofits, overall donor retention was 43.3%. First-time donors were retained at 18.9% and repeat donors at 59.3%.
- Larger donors give again more often. In the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's 2025 data, retention was 69.5% for donors in the $50,000-and-up band and 31.3% for donors in the $1-to-$100 band.
- Donors who give more often are more likely to give again. In the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's 2025 data, donors who gave once in the prior year were retained at 31.9%, twice at 51.9%, and three to six times at 70.0%.
- LYBUNT donors gave last fiscal year but not yet this one. SYBUNT donors gave earlier but not in the current or prior fiscal year. Together, the two lists hold every past donor who has not given this fiscal year.
Donor retention rate is the share of last year’s donors who gave again this year: the donors who gave in both years, divided by all of last year’s donors, times 100. In 2025 data from the Fundraising Effectiveness Project (FEP), overall retention was 43.3%, first-time donors were retained at 18.9%, and repeat donors at 59.3%. Donor churn is the other side of the same number: 100% minus your retention rate.
What is donor retention rate?
Donor retention rate is the percentage of donors from one period who give again in the next. The usual period is a year: count last year’s donors, count how many gave again this year, and divide. A nonprofit with 1,000 donors last year and 430 of them giving again has a 43% retention rate and a 57% churn rate.
| Metric | Formula |
|---|---|
| Donor retention rate | Last year’s donors who gave again this year ÷ all of last year’s donors × 100 |
| Donor churn rate | 100% minus the donor retention rate |
| First-time donor retention | Last year’s first-time donors who gave again ÷ all of last year’s first-time donors × 100 |
| Repeat donor retention | Last year’s repeat donors who gave again ÷ all of last year’s repeat donors × 100 |
How to calculate donor retention rate
To calculate donor retention rate, divide the number of last year’s donors who gave again this year by the number of donors who gave last year, then multiply by 100. If 430 of last year’s 1,000 donors gave again, your retention rate is 43%. Use the same period every time, and count each donor once.
- Pick the period. Use your fiscal year if your board reports on it, and keep the same period every time.
- List every donor who gave in the earlier year. Count each donor once, however many gifts they made.
- Count how many of those donors gave again in the later year. New donors from the later year do not count.
- Divide the second number by the first, and multiply by 100.
- Run the same math for first-time and repeat donors separately, and for your gift-size bands. One blended number hides where donors leave.
Credit donor-advised fund grants and gifts made through an employer to the donor who chose to give, or your rate will undercount the people who stayed.
What is a good donor retention rate?
A good donor retention rate is one above the benchmark for your mix of donors. In the Fundraising Effectiveness Project’s 2025 data, overall retention was 43.3%. Compare first-time and repeat donors separately: FEP’s 2025 benchmarks were 18.9% for first-time donors and 59.3% for repeat donors. A file with many first-time donors shows a lower blended rate.
| Donor type (FEP, 2025) | Rate |
|---|---|
| All donors | 43.3% |
| First-time donors | 18.9% |
| Repeat donors | 59.3% |
| Previously lapsed donors who gave again (recapture) | 3.0% |
Retention also rises with donor size, which FEP measures by a donor’s total giving for the year. In FEP’s 2025 data, by its own size bands:
| FEP size band | Retention rate |
|---|---|
| Micro ($1 to $100) | 31.3% |
| Small ($101 to $500) | 49.7% |
| Midsize ($501 to $5K) | 61.7% |
| Major ($5K to $50K) | 66.9% |
| Supersize ($50K and up) | 69.5% |
Retention slipped in 2025 in every band except $50K and up, even though the overall rate held about level. That is the same concentration the 80/20 rule describes: the largest donors give most of the money, and they are also the likeliest to stay.
FEP, run by the AFP Foundation for Philanthropy and GivingTuesday, pools 7.8 million donors at 15,102 nonprofits that each raise less than $25 million a year. FEP estimates that its donor count fell 3.6% in 2025 while dollars rose 5.0%, and FEP traces almost all of that growth to donors who gave $5,000 or more.
What is donor churn?
Donor churn is the share of donors who stop giving over a period, the opposite of retention. Churn can be voluntary, when a donor decides to stop, or involuntary, when a recurring gift fails on an expired card or a returned bank draft. Involuntary churn is often the easiest to win back, because the donor never chose to leave.
Two lists track churn. LYBUNT donors gave in your last fiscal year and have not given so far in this one. SYBUNT donors gave in an earlier year but not in the current or prior fiscal year. LYBUNT donors are your best renewal list before year-end; SYBUNT donors need a reason to come back.
How to reduce donor churn
- Win the second gift. In FEP’s 2025 data, donors who gave twice in the prior year were retained at 51.9%, against 31.9% for donors who gave once. A prompt thank-you and a specific second ask in the first months give that gift its best chance. Our post on the 90-day second-gift rule lays out the first 90 days step by step.
- Report impact between asks. Donors who hear what their last gift did have a reason to give again.
- Invite monthly giving. Donors who give more often are more likely to give again: in FEP’s 2025 data, donors who gave three to six times in the prior year were retained at 70.0%.
- Fix failed recurring payments every month. Contact the donor before the next scheduled gift, while the plan is still active.
- Work the LYBUNT list before your fiscal year ends, and tell donors which date a December gift counts in.
For a full plan, see our step-by-step guide to raising donor retention, and write the thank-you and update schedule into a stewardship plan.
Ignite, the Active Intelligence Platform from StratusLIVE, keeps these lists current without a monthly pull. Its 50+ ready-made segments include LYBUNT, SYBUNT, Lapsed, Renewed from Lapse, and Recurring Payment Failed; they refresh daily, and the rule behind each one is visible in the platform. The Recurring Payment Failed segment lists sustainers whose latest recurring payment failed, so a monthly gift that fails in March shows up after the next daily refresh. See how Ignite helps you retain more donors.
Frequently asked questions
What is the average donor retention rate?
In the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's data for 2025, overall donor retention was an estimated 43.3%, about level with 43.1% in 2024. First-time donors were retained at 18.9% and repeat donors at 59.3%. The FEP figures pool 7.8 million donors at 15,102 nonprofits. Your own rate depends on your mix of first-time and repeat donors.
What is a good first-time donor retention rate?
Anything above 18.9% beats the 2025 average for first-time donors in the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's data, unchanged from 2024. About four in five first-time donors did not give again in 2025. FEP calls turning a first gift into a second the most consequential unsolved problem in the donor pipeline. In FEP's 2025 data, donors who gave twice in the prior year were retained at 51.9%, against 31.9% for donors who gave once.
How do you calculate donor churn rate?
Subtract your donor retention rate from 100%. If 1,000 donors gave last year and 430 of them gave again this year, retention is 43% and churn is 57%. You can also count it directly: last year's donors who did not give again, divided by all of last year's donors, times 100. Track churn for first-time and repeat donors separately.
What is the difference between donor retention and donor churn?
They measure the same donors from opposite sides. Retention is the share of last year's donors who gave again; churn is the share who did not. A 43% retention rate means 57% churn. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project reports retention, so retention is the easier number to compare with a published benchmark.
What are LYBUNT and SYBUNT donors?
LYBUNT stands for Last Year But Unfortunately Not This year: a donor who gave in your last fiscal year and has not given so far in this one. SYBUNT stands for Some Year But Unfortunately Not This year: a donor who gave in an earlier year but not in the current or prior fiscal year. LYBUNT donors are your best renewal list; SYBUNT donors need a reason to come back. Definitions vary between donor databases, so check your system's rule before you compare lists.
Should I measure donor retention by fiscal year or calendar year?
Use the year your board and finance team report on, and keep it the same every time. A fiscal-year rate lines up with your LYBUNT and SYBUNT lists. The Fundraising Effectiveness Project reports calendar years, so compare your calendar-year rate with its benchmarks. Do not mix the two periods in one trend.
What is involuntary donor churn?
Involuntary churn is giving that ends without the donor deciding to stop, usually a recurring gift that fails on an expired card or a returned bank draft. It is often the easiest churn to recover, because the donor never chose to leave. Review failed recurring payments every month, and contact the donor before the next scheduled gift.
Is a 50% donor retention rate good?
It depends on your mix of donors. A 50% rate is above the Fundraising Effectiveness Project's 2025 overall rate of 43.3%, but below its 59.3% rate for repeat donors. A file made up mostly of first-time donors is doing well at 50%. A file of mostly repeat donors at 50% is losing more of them than the benchmark.
