Skip to content

How to score two nonprofit CRM finalists side by side.

Give both vendors the same five tasks and the same sample of your data, then score only what you see done live. The StratusLIVE Finalist Scorecard has seven categories and 100 points, and it works for any two systems.

Free to use and to print. No form.

Three rules before the demos

Most final demos go wrong the same way. Each vendor shows its best screens, the team likes both, and the decision comes down to who presented better. A scorecard fixes that only if you set it up first.

  1. 1. Send both vendors the same script

    Two weeks before the demos, send each vendor the five tasks below and a sample of your own data: a few hundred donor records, with the duplicates and the odd gift types left in. Clean demo data hides the problems you will live with.

  2. 2. Use the same scorers, scoring alone

    The same people attend both demos. Each person scores in writing before anyone talks. The first opinion spoken in a room tends to become the room’s opinion.

  3. 3. Score only what you see done

    If the answer is a slide, or "yes, we can do that," the line scores zero today. Ask the vendor to come back and show it.

Set the weights before the first demo too. If you change them after you have seen both systems, you are choosing a winner and then building the math to match.

The scorecard: seven categories, 100 points

Each category names one thing the vendor does live. Score each finalist in its own column.

CategoryWeightWhat the vendor does liveWhy it countsFinalist AFinalist B
1. Daily fundraising work20Enters a pledge with a payment schedule, and one gift split across two funds.Your gift processor does this thousands of times. Count the clicks and the screens.__ / 5__ / 5
2. Gift to ledger15Traces that split gift to its general ledger entry.If development and finance reconcile by spreadsheet today, this category shows if that ends. Have your finance lead in the room.__ / 5__ / 5
3. Reports your board asks for15Builds one of your real board reports from a blank screen.A finished dashboard proves less than a report built in front of you.__ / 5__ / 5
4. Data migration15Loads your sample file, shows the records with errors, and undoes the import.Ask if you can check an import before it commits, and who does the work: their team or yours.__ / 5__ / 5
5. AI, with controls10Shows what the AI prepares, who approves it, and where the approval is logged.A feature that nobody on your team can review will not get used.__ / 5__ / 5
6. Staff adoption10One of your staff, who was not part of the search, does one task with no help.Watch how far they get in five minutes.__ / 5__ / 5
7. Five-year cost and contract15Gives the five-year cost in writing, and the terms to get your data out.Ask for licenses, implementation, data migration, support and the price of adding users, and the export format if you leave.__ / 5__ / 5
Total100__ / 100__ / 100

The five-task demo script

Send these five tasks to both vendors, with your sample file and one real board report. Change the details to match your week.

  1. Enter a pledge with a payment schedule for an existing donor.
  2. Enter one gift split across two funds, then show its general ledger entry.
  3. Build this board report from a blank screen. (Attach one real report.)
  4. Load the attached sample file. Show the records with errors, then undo the import.
  5. Build a list of lapsed donors and a drafted note for each one. Show who approves the notes and where that is logged.

Two categories need no task from the vendor. For staff adoption, your own staff member repeats task 1. For five-year cost and contract, ask for the answer in writing before the demo.

How to score each line

  • 0Not shown.
  • 1Described, and not shown.
  • 3Shown, with a workaround.
  • 5Shown as asked, in your data.

Divide the line score by 5 and multiply by the category weight. Add the seven categories, and each system has a score out of 100. Then average the scorers.

Look at the lines where two scorers differ by two points or more. Talk about those lines first, because two people saw different things.

What to do when the scores are close

If the two totals are within five points, the scorecard has not picked for you. Go back to two categories: staff adoption and five-year cost. The system your team will use, at a cost you have in writing, is the safer choice.

Then call two customers of each vendor who are your size. Ask each one what surprised them in the first year.

Who made this

StratusLIVE makes Ignite, a nonprofit platform where fundraising, finance, and marketing work from one constituent record. If we are one of your two finalists, send us the same script you send the other one.

Cite as: StratusLIVE Finalist Scorecard, updated 2026-11-17. StratusLIVE. stratuslive.com/tools/nonprofit-crm-finalist-scorecard/

Questions about scoring CRM finalists.

How do you score two nonprofit CRM finalists side by side?

Give both vendors the same five tasks and the same sample of your data, then score only what you see done live. The StratusLIVE Finalist Scorecard uses seven weighted categories that add up to 100 points. Each scorer rates every line from 0 to 5, alone and in writing, and the team averages the results.

What should a nonprofit CRM demo scorecard include?

Seven categories cover the decision: daily fundraising work, gift to ledger, the reports your board asks for, data migration, AI with controls, staff adoption, and five-year cost and contract. Each category names one task the vendor performs live, so the score reflects what the team saw.

How should the categories be weighted?

Set the weights before the first demo and do not change them after. The default gives 20 points to daily fundraising work, 15 each to gift to ledger, board reports, data migration, and five-year cost and contract, and 10 each to AI with controls and staff adoption. Move points to match your priorities, and keep the total at 100.

What if the two finalists score almost the same?

If the totals are within five points, the scorecard has not picked for you. Go back to two categories: staff adoption and five-year cost. Then call two customers of each vendor who are your size, and ask each one what surprised them in the first year.

Run the same script with us.

Bring your five tasks and your sample data to a working session, and score what you see.